Event Report: Storm Desmond and A591: Damage and Repair

Lecture by Dr. Simon Ferley

Wednesday 12th October 2016

Dr Ferley began from first principles. He considered the properties of soil and the way it’s strength varied with water content, which he demonstrated with samples from his own garden. He then went on to describe the different ways in which slopes fail with some mathematical equations enhanced by some very clear diagrams. It became abundantly clear that water content is crucial to the stability of any slope and that appropriate drainage is essential to prevent failure.

He then discussed measures which could be taken to mitigate naturally occurring failures. These included good maintenance of channels downstream, delaying flow in areas nearer the catchment by tree planting and creating artificial meanders in a stream. He was cautious about flood defences as although they are necessary in some areas, they may exacerbate problems downstream.

Dr. Ferley had some dramatic photographs of rock and soil failures both from this country and abroad, almost all due to inappropriate engineering works rather than natural events.

He finished with a quick resume of the cause of the devastation to the A591 which had been due to excessive rainfall that had, by natural processes, been channeled into a steep, narrow gully.

Susan Beale

Event Report: The Sirius Minerals North Yorkshire Polyhalite Project, 21st September

The Sirius Minerals North Yorkshire Polyhalite Project

Tristan Pottas, was unable to give this talk but two of his colleagues gave an interesting overview of this exciting new mining project near Whitby. Asher Haynes described the process of exploration and the excitement of discovering a truly vast deposit of polyhalite in North Yorkshire. Polyhalite is an unusual multi-nutrient mineral that is an exceptionally good fertilizer as it is essentially chloride free, does not affect the pH of the groundwater when applied, and needs virtually no processing. However this valuable resource lies 1500m below the National Park with all its tight planning restrictions. Nevertheless the project would bring significant economic benefits to the area by way of employment and would contribute to the national economy. Sirius had been given planning consent after describing these advantages and developing an extraction method which placed most of the infrastructure below ground level. The Company are currently seeking the necessary finance in readiness to commence construction.

David Warburton, completed the evening by describing the characteristics of polyhalite (K 2 MgCa 2 (SO 4 ) 4 2H 2 O) and his recent research Masters degree at University of Leeds where he had attempted to discover how this mineral is formed. This deposit is most unusual in its thickness, averaging 25m, whereas deposits of around a metre are the norm. Polyhalite is a late stage mineral to form in a sequence of evaporates, so how does such a huge volume occur? David attacked the problem from a geochemical perspective, looking at the isotopes of the various elements which all pointed to formation from seawater during Permian time. The study of thin sections by the BGS suggested that polyhalite replaced anhydrite and other minerals, very soon after the original crystals had formed. The results support the formation of polyhalite via seawater concentration processes, though the topic is far from closed and much more research could be completed.

The combination of a more sustainable approach to the extraction of a valuable resource and the attempts to discover its formation and the questions raised made for a fascinating evening. The speakers were both enthusiastic and hopefully will return in due course to update us on their progress.

Event Reminder: Storm Desmond and A591: Damage and Repair

Cumberland Geological Society Presents –
From the Winter Lecture Events Programme:

Wednesday 12th October 2016

Storm Desmond and A591: Damage and Repair

Starts: 19:30

Location: Penrith Methodist Church Hall, Penrith

This meeting will now be held at Penrith Methodist Church Hall.
(the Meeting House at Keswick is still being repaired from flood damage)
Description:

Dr. Simon Ferley: Storm Desmond and A591: Damage and Repair

Crinkle Crags Excursion 7th September Report

Crinkle Crags Excursion 7th September led by Clive Boulter

On the sunny morning of 7th September 20 members met at Three Shires Stone. On the long haul up to the Crinkles a couple of brief stops were made to prevent the party from being strung out too much and to catch breath! The first of these was at Red Tarn where small pieces of kidney and pencil ore mark small spoil tips and there is documentary evidence of workings in the 1600s and trials in the mid 1800s though suggestions of medieval activity exist. Half way up the steady climb to Long Top a fine example of welded ignimbrite introduced the topic of the day. Soon low cloud enveloped the party as we left the path and with visibility reduced to 20m it was essential to stay together.

Fortunately by the time we reached our first locality on the side of Adam-a-Cove the cloud had lifted and we could examine the point at which Hell was unleashed. Not wishing to enter the debate about distinguishing lava flows from peperitic sills the leader focused our attention on the pyroclastic rocks that mark the change from dominantly effusive behavior [Birker Fell Formation] to explosive caldera-forming eruptions; these started with a hundred or so metres of andesitic ignimbrite [Whorneyside Formation] before switching to rhyolitic composition [Airy’s Bridge Formation]. The lowermost few metres of the caldera fill has metric-scale alternations of welded and non-welded [cross-bedded] ignimbrite which were attributed to changes in the density of the pyroclastic currents. A diagonal walk towards Stonesty Pike allowed the magnitude of the pile of welded andesitic ignimbrite to be appreciated.

On Stonesty Pike a magnificent exposure of the Whorneyside andesitic bedded tuff revealed much about how it was formed and its subsequent eventful life. Typically around 30 metres thick, the tuff shows no signs of sedimentary structures but it is poorly sorted. This conundrum is resolved by observing the infills to erosional rills where the layers maintain their vertical thickness and hence prove an airfall origin. It appears that the andesite magma was intensely fragmented over a period of months when 20 to 30 km3 of water got into the magma chamber creating the largest phreatomagmatic eruption of all time. There is plenty of evidence of a moist eruption as there are many coated pellet [accretionary lapilli] layers which prove useful marker horizons for the thrust faults common in the exposure. These faults show that the removal of magma from the chamber was already leading to the breakup of the roof into variably tilted blocks bounded by volcano-tectonic faults. Centimetre-scale impact sags showed that some lapilli were sent on ballistic paths in the eruption.

Approximately along strike the angular unconformity between the darker, andesitic Whorneyside Tuff and the lighter, rhyolitic Stonesty Tuff was clearly seen. However this did not represent a large time gap but rather that a huge block of tuff had toppled, undergone erosion, and been covered by the Stonesty Tuff. It is difficult to estimate the time gap but in the context of a progressively evolving caldera these events took place in less time than it takes a thick ignimbrite to cool.

The next locality was a rather insignificant looking small exposure which marked the Isaac Gill Fault, a volcano-tectonic fault with more than 200 metres of offset. Abrupt rotation of bedding in the Whorneyside phreatoplinian tuff was seen a couple of metres from the slack occupied by the fault. The next locality provided key evidence for the origin of these faults during piecemeal caldera-collapse. In the rhyolitic welded ignimbrite the fiamme were seen to bend from their normal gentle dip continuously into a near vertical attitude towards a minor volcano-tectonic fault. These faults were clearly active whilst the ignimbrites were still hot and capable of ductile flow.

Our final location involved a climb to just below the summit to examine the Hanging Stone Tuff packed with multiply-rimmed pellets [accretionary lapilli], and many fragmented rims. Several similar horizons punctuate the rhyolitic pile of ignimbrites and prove a very useful means to identify individual units. Cross bedding in the tuff shows it formed form a pyroclastic current at the lower end of the density spectrum and marks small volumes of water getting into contact with the magma. When all the party had safely regained the path, still in good weather, an enthusiastic vote of thanks was given to our leader, Clive Boulter for a fascinating day on the high fells.

Venue Change: Storm Desmond and A591: Damage and Repair

Cumberland Geological Society Presents –
From the Winter Lecture Events Programme:

Wednesday 12th October 2016

Storm Desmond and A591: Damage and Repair

Starts: 19:30

Location: Penrith Methodist Church Hall, Penrith

This meeting will now be held at Penrith Methodist Church Hall.
(the Meeting House at Keswick is still being repaired from flood damage)
Description:

Dr. Simon Ferley: Storm Desmond and A591: Damage and Repair

47 KB 240 by 258 pixels
Privacy Overview

Using this website you agree to our privacy policy available at Privacy Notice. This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.